Reading time: 9 minutes
You've raised wages twice this year. You're paying above market. And your best caregivers are still quitting.
Here's what Activated Insights found after 40,000+ caregiver interviews: the number one reason caregivers leave is poor communication with the office. Not pay. Not hours. Not difficult clients.
And honestly? That's good news. Because unlike wages, communication is something you can fix tomorrow morning.
What This Is Actually Costing You
Quick math. The average agency hires about 81 caregivers a year. Industry turnover hit 75% in the most recent Activated Insights benchmarking report. That means roughly 61 of those people will be gone before December.
Replacing one caregiver runs about $2,600 when you add up recruiting, interviewing, onboarding, and training. Multiply that out and you're looking at $158,000+ in annual turnover costs. Mid-sized agencies routinely burn through $300K a year just churning staff.
The research backs this up. 57% of employees have quit a job specifically because of poor communication from leadership. In home care, 80% of turnover happens in the first 90 days. That's your communication window. And "lack of communication" is the single most common complaint in caregiver satisfaction surveys. Every. Single. Year.
The frustrating part? By the time you notice someone's unhappy, they've already mentally quit. They're just waiting for a better offer to make it official.
What "Poor Communication" Actually Means
When caregivers complain about communication, they're not talking about one thing. It's death by a thousand cuts:
The ignored text. A caregiver messages you at 2 PM about a problem with a client. Nobody responds until the next day. Or ever. She spends her whole shift feeling abandoned. By Friday, she's on Indeed.
Schedule chaos. Shifts get moved around with zero explanation. One week it's 35 hours, the next it's 18. Caregivers can't plan childcare, can't budget, can't live. They find someone who respects their time.
The feedback void. Your caregiver has been working for four months. She has no idea if she's doing well or terribly. Is she about to get fired? Does anyone notice she exists? The uncertainty eats at her until she leaves for a job where someone actually talks to her.
The onboarding ghost. You spend a week training someone, then... nothing. Radio silence. No check-ins. No "how's it going?" The data shows 4 out of 5 caregivers who quit do it within the first 100 days. This is why.
Sound familiar?
You know that sinking feeling when your best caregiver, the one families request by name, texts you "can we talk?" You already know what's coming. And you wonder: what did I miss? What could I have done differently? The answer, almost always, is that you stopped talking to her somewhere around week three.
The Trap You're Probably Stuck In
Before we get to fixes, you need to understand why this matters right now. Not someday.
89% of agencies have had to turn away clients because they don't have enough staff. The average agency refuses 510 care hours every month. That's families who needed help and couldn't get it. Referral sources who stop calling because you're always at capacity.
Poor communication causes turnover. Turnover creates staffing shortages. Shortages force you to turn away clients. Turning away clients strains your remaining caregivers. Overworked caregivers quit.
Round and round. Every month you don't fix this, the hole gets deeper.
Don't have bandwidth to fix your retention problems alone?
We help home care agencies build communication systems that actually keep caregivers. Book a free strategy call to talk through what's costing you staff.
Why Throwing Money at This Won't Work
Look, paying more does help retention. Recent data shows agencies at the 75th percentile for wages see 35.5% lower turnover. That's real.
But here's the thing nobody wants to hear: communication fixes get you similar results without blowing up your budget. A caregiver making $18/hour who feels ignored will still quit. The pattern repeats across the industry. Money doesn't fix feeling invisible.
Where your caregivers come from matters too. Indeed hires have 88% turnover. Word-of-mouth referrals? Just 59%, and they cost about $520 to acquire versus the higher cost of job board recruiting.
That 29-point gap is wild. Why do referrals stick around? They came in with realistic expectations. They already know someone at the agency. They're plugged into the communication network from day one.
The common thread isn't money. It's connection.
Five Fixes That Actually Move the Needle
I'm not going to give you a 47-step implementation guide. These are the things that actually work, based on what low-turnover agencies do differently:
1. Scheduled Check-Ins (Yes, Actually Schedule Them)
The first 100 days make or break retention. You need touchpoints at day 7, day 30, day 60, and day 90. Put them in your calendar. Treat them like client meetings.
Week one: quick daily texts. "How'd your first shift go?" Day 30: actual phone call with a supervisor. This is where you catch problems before they become two-week notices.
By day 60, caregivers know if this job works for them. Surface whatever they've been afraid to say. Day 90: if they're still here, they're worth keeping. Ask what would make them stay another year. Actually listen.
This isn't rocket science. But almost nobody does it consistently.
2. Get a Real Communication System
Your caregivers aren't sitting at desks. They're in clients' homes, in their cars, juggling six things at once. If your communication strategy is "hope they check email," you've already lost.
You need a centralized platform they can access from their phone. When Maria has a problem at 3 PM, she shouldn't have to wonder who to text, whether anyone will see it, or if she'll get in trouble for bothering the office.
It's not about the software. It's about response time. Agencies that respond fast keep more people. Period.
3. Pair New Hires With a Buddy
Match every new caregiver with someone experienced for their first month. Not a manager. A peer.
The buddy is the safe person to ask "stupid" questions. Where do I park at this client's house? Is it okay to use my phone during downtime? What's the deal with the scheduler? New caregivers are drowning in uncertainty. Give them a lifeline.
Agencies using success coaches or buddy systems report retention rates as high as 97% among caregivers who actively engage with the program.
4. Recognition (More Than Once a Year)
This stat blew my mind: 5 recognition moments per year drops turnover from 15% to 7%. Twelve recognition moments? Turnover falls to 2%.
We're not talking expensive gifts. A specific text. "The client's daughter called to say how much her mom loves you." A shout-out in the team chat. A handwritten note once a quarter. That's it.
Most agencies recognize caregivers once a year at the holiday party. That's not recognition. That's checking a box.
5. Anonymous Feedback (Before They Quit)
Exit interviews are worthless. By then, they're either being polite or they're too burned out to care. You need feedback while people are still employed and problems are still fixable.
Anonymous surveys work. Caregivers will tell you about scheduling frustrations, problem clients, and office drama when their name isn't attached. Third-party tools like Activated Insights work. A simple Google Form works too.
The agencies with the best retention don't just collect feedback. They visibly act on it. When caregivers see their input change something, trust builds fast.
The Evidence: Training, Communication, and Real Results
The correlation between training and revenue surprised me.
Agencies with 8+ hours of orientation hit $2.4M in median revenue. Those with 3 hours or less? $2.03M. The gap is real. Agencies offering 5+ training hours see 27% lower turnover than their peers. And those providing 12+ hours of ongoing training bring in roughly $55K more in annual revenue.
Training isn't just about skills. It's dedicated time when someone is paying attention to your new hire. Teaching them. Answering questions. Making them feel like the agency actually cares whether they succeed. That's communication. And it shows up directly in the numbers.
Proof It Works: Family Resource Home Care
Family Resource Home Care, a 1,500-employee agency with 22 locations, was losing caregivers despite having a solid orientation program. Their Activated Insights surveys revealed the problem: caregivers felt undertrained for individual client needs. They didn't know what resources were already available to them.
The fix wasn't new training. It was communication about the training they already had. As CEO Jeff Wiberg put it: "We never stop talking about what we are actually doing."
Result: 7% improvement in 90-day retention, and their best quarter in history for keeping caregivers. All from telling people what was already available to them.
Source: Activated Insights Customer Stories
The Ultimate Marketing Checklist for Home Care
15-point GBP audit, review generation templates, recruitment ad examples, website conversion checklist, and social media calendar.
Get the Free ChecklistWant Expert Help With Retention?
You now know what's causing turnover. But implementing these changes while running an agency is hard. That's exactly why GrowCare Team exists. We help agencies build the systems that keep caregivers.
Book a Free Strategy Call15 minutes. No pitch. Just an honest look at your retention challenges.
So What Now?
Home care's 75% turnover rate isn't because caregivers are greedy. Most of them aren't leaving for more money. They're leaving because they feel invisible.
The good news? You can fix invisible. Unlike wages, it doesn't require board approval. Unlike the labor market, it's completely in your control.
Pick one thing. Maybe it's the 7/30/60/90 check-ins. Maybe it's a buddy system. Start there. Watch what happens to your retention over the next quarter. Then add the next piece.
Your caregivers want to feel like they matter. The ones who stay will be the ones who do.
